Analogies & First Principles
One of the most helpful rules that I’ve learned in my perpetual search for truth has been to be careful of analogies (and similes) that are stated as fact.
I’ve seen a lot of NFT “takedowns” lately that use this tactic apparently to great effect.
As I wrote about last week, people mostly learn and innovate by making connections between ideas/observations. It’s a powerful shortcut to apply familiar, overarching concepts from one area to another when exploring a completely foreign idea like NFTs.
But these shortcuts can also be the enemy of true understanding. Just because something can be like another thing in one sense, does not make the two things the same in every way. Humans are really good at building compelling narratives. Similarities narrow in scope used to make broad, unrelated proclamations are where analogies go awry.
The map is not the territory is a related saying/concept. We’re not equipped to fully comprehend all of reality, but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t attempt to dig deeper.
First principles thinking is that attempt to better understand reality and the counterbalance for reasoning by analogy. Elon Musk is a famous practitioner of first principles thinking. He’s done ok for himself.
It takes a lot of time and hard work to break things down to the most basic elements then build up ideas and connections from there. None of us can function like that all the time. But if we can catch ourselves and others in making overreaching analogies more often, then we’ll be more equipped to navigate the uncertainty of new innovations like NFTs.
- One of our long-time community members, Brian, has jumped in and gotten busy contributing to the Geo Web’s core contracts and infrastructure. To this point, it’s mostly been a one-man show with Cody leading our smart contract development. With Brian joining the fun, I think this will be a 1 + 1 > 2 situation.
- We merged two WIP AR/VR use cases into our Geo Web Experiments repo. More to come!
- We have plenty of knitting to take care of with the core tech of the Geo Web before governance becomes our top focus. But in the long-term, governance is equally important to the trajectory of the project as the tech itself, so we’re constantly evaluating and following innovators/innovations in the space. Matt Prewitt from RadicalxChange published a really interesting sketch of a governance system that combines some of our favorite mechanisms that’s definitely worth a read.
- Friend of the project, Will Holley, has been hard at work developing open -source templates/modules for partial common ownership NFTs. We’re bullish on PCO assets for the Geo Web obviously, but the opportunities go so far beyond our niche. We’re stoked to see Will’s progress and what it can mean for the space. #WAGMI
- I’m going to take the next two weeks off from the blog for ETHDenver and the Mountain Retreat. If you’ll be attending one or the other, hit me up on Discord (graven#6675)—especially if you drop by any of the BUIDLWeek events at 1134 Broadway where I’ll be hanging out Monday - Thursday.