In the offline world, I’m always up for a good debate with my friends and family—much to their chagrin sometimes. It’s just one of those things core to who I am.
I find it intellectually stimulating/fun, and I want to find/share the “truth.” (Acknowledgment: I, of course, get too stuck in my own line of thinking sometimes.)
Outside of my friends and family, I rarely engage in debate. Why? Political views are entrenched. Online interactions can quickly turn ugly. The roots of disagreement seem to sprout from living in different realities. Trying to change strangers’ minds head-on with words can have the opposite effect.
There are persuasive people out there with the ability and commitment to do it effectively at scale—for better and worse. I don’t see myself as one of them though, so I don’t put much effort into attempting it. (I think of this blog as a way to sharpen my personal thoughts more than anything.)
At my core, I’m still passionate about finding and spreading good ideas though. So, I try to channel my efforts into action and outcomes to change minds. Make the idea come to life rather than leave it abstract. There might not be explicit acknowledgment, internally or externally, of converting a previous detractor, but their actions are ultimately what matters. That’s how to “win” the debate.
The Geo Web’s partial common ownership (PCO) system challenges one of the assumed core tenants of the capitalist system: private property rights. For some, private property rights are thought of as a human right. We clearly have a tough road ahead in changing minds if we want to succeed.
I’m not old enough to have grown up in the Cold War. But, I’ve read and debated enough to broadly understand the source of near-religious defense of capitalism/property rights. Capitalism vs. communism was good vs. evil in the fight for the future of humanity. Words alone aren’t going to be enough for most capitalists to “give up” their private property rights.
Lost in the good vs. evil framing is that property rights/economic systems are social fictions: technologies that can be more or less useful depending on their designs. In this dispassionate framing, they can and should be innovated upon.
Private property beats out common property at scale because it creates superior incentive structures and information processing systems (that’s not to say the commons can’t be well managed).
Partial common ownership will beat out private property for effectively the same reasons. PCO creates superior incentive structures and information processing systems.
That’s the idea we want to convince the world of. And the beauty is that people don’t need to take our word for it.
We’ll prove it, permissionlessly, with a greenfield property right (geospatial augmented reality). We’ll create a dynamic and ultimately more productive free market for digital land. We’ll reinvest all the market funds into public goods creating a rising tide for all boats. The economic flywheel will compound collective and individual value.
If our theories prove to be true, we’ll convert the die-hard capitalists through cold-hard economic reality and self-interest—even if an allusion to “common ownership” previously sent a shiver up their spine.
- We released a backlog of Cadastre changes including PCO tooltips, max parcel size claims, map updates, a new landing page, and Ceramic/IPFS publishing improvements. Check it out at https://geoweb.land/ if you haven’t yet. More to come!
- New contributor tnrdd completed an upgrade of our react-map-gl version that should include some performance improvements and implemented a max parcel claim feature (https://github.com/Geo-Web-Project/cadastre/pull/202 & https://github.com/Geo-Web-Project/cadastre/pull/200).
- We had two really awesome conversations with a core engineer and a DevRel rep from Optimism. We’ve long been aligned with their public goods vision but were really impressed with their technical vision for Optimistic Ethereum. This blog was a really insightful take on the potential transition from optimistic rollups to zk rollups that I hadn’t seen shared widely through official channels yet.
- I’ve been in grant writing mode this and last week. The final external blockers standing between us and our mainnet are lifting. That means it's on us to stay focused and deliver. Being able to pay a full-time, dedicated team during this critical period is the goal, so if you are part of any grant-giving orgs or can make intros shoot me a DM (#graven6675 on Discord).
- Contributor and friend of the Geo Web project, Will Holley, proposed a CIP in CityDAO to create a web3 city based on partial common ownership (and other complementary ideas). If you’re a CityDAO citizen and haven’t interacted with the proposal, we’d encourage you to do so. We’re big believers in PCO and want to see it spread and thrive in lots of contexts, so we’re stoked to see this proposal.
- Grant application submissions
- More Cadastre updates
- Superfluid architecture design